Book Review

PoPB: Carlo and the Really Nice Librarian by Jessica Spanyol and The Day the Crayons Quit by Drew Daywalt & Oliver Jeffers.

Pair of Picture Books Tuesdays on Juniper’s Jungle bring two reviews of picture books.

Carlo and the Really Nice Librarian by Jessica Spanyol. Walker Books.
CarloIn a simple storybook adventure, curious Carlo discovers the joys of the library with the help of a gentle (if toothy) librarian.

Carlo the giraffe is making his first visit to the new library. “Wow!” he says when he sees all the books, the colorful posters, and especially the chairs with wheels. But Carlo is a little afraid of the librarian, Mrs. Chinca, with her sharp teeth and claws, until he learns how much she loves books. With bright illustrations and a cheery text, Jessica Spanyol offers preschoolers a spirited introduction to the library — and a really nice librarian.

I am a big fan of picture books that show a character going to do something for the first time, particularly when its something to do with reading. This book tells the story of Carlo’s first trip to the library, he loves books and reading and instantly falls in love with the place. It takes him a little longer to fall in love with Mrs Chinca, the librarian, mainly because she initially seems a little scary. I enjoyed the story but felt that in its effort to be simple and cute it ended up being a little underwhelming, neither the idea of joining the library or of getting to know someone instead of judging them on their appearance ended up being dealt with as fully as I would have liked.

The illustrations in the book are fun, bold and colourful. This is the second book I’ve read that is written and illustrated by Jessica Spanyol, after loving the look of the first one (Go Bugs Go!) I had high hopes for this and I was not disappointed. The pages are very busy but not overwhelming, I really enjoyed how much there was to look at on every page.

The Day the Crayons Quit by Drew Daywalt & Oliver Jeffers (illustrator). HarperCollins Children’s Books.
TheDayTheCrayonsQuitPoor Duncan just wants to color. But when he opens his box of crayons, he finds only letters, all saying the same thing: We quit!

Beige is tired of playing second fiddle to Brown. Blue needs a break from coloring all that water, while Pink just wants to be used. Green has no complaints, but Orange and Yellow are no longer speaking to each other.

What is Duncan to do? Debut author Drew Daywalt and New York Times bestseller Oliver Jeffers create a colorful solution in this playful, imaginative story that will have children laughing and playing with their crayons in a whole new way.

I absolutely loved this book, as soon as I finished reading it I added it to my shortlist of books for my next Beaver Scout Sleepover and to my books to buy for children I know list. It’s clever and enchanting and cute and just brilliant. It tells the stories of Drew’s crayons. They’ve gone on strike, leaving behind letters to explain why. For the different coloured crayons there are different reasons, some are feeling over-used, some under-used and some are in the middle of a feud over who gets to be the official colour for the sun. Regardless of why they’re on strike each crayon’s letter is both funny and thought-provoking, each makes its case very well for the strike action.

Having a cute and clever plot is only half of the story. The illustrations by the ever brilliant Oliver Jeffers add so much to this book. Each double page spread contains the same key elements; the letter, handwritten in the relevant colour, a picture of the crayon and some of the pictures that crayon has been responsible for. These all work so well together, they each support the other elements and add a richness to the reading experience. The resolution of the plot brings a couple more lovely illustrations, I particularly liked the very last one.

Both books featured in this post were borrowed from my local library.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s