Book Review

PoP: Katie in Scotland by James Mayhew & Steggie’s Stammer by Jack Hughes.

PoP Tuesdays on Juniper’s Jungle bring two reviews of picture books.

Katie in Scotland by James Mayhew. Orchard Books.
KatieInScotlandKatie, Jack and Grandma are on holiday in Scotland! There’s lots to see and do, so where should they start? Loch Ness, of course! And when Nessie wants to join them on their holiday, fun is bound to follow!

Join Katie on her latest adventure as she discovers the wonderful delights that Scotland has to offer.

This is a fun, light-hearted read about Katie’s visit to Scotland. Within the first couple of pages she meets Nessie (for this is what the Loch Ness Monster asks them to call her) who proceeds to act as travel companion and sometimes tour guide. They take in the sights in both Glasgow and Edinburgh over the course of the book. It’s a good introduction to Scotland and could be a nice book to share before a family trip.

The illustrations in the book are lovely, they use a slightly soft palette which works well with the gentle story. I had a couple of favourite double page illustrations – early in the book there is a beautiful panorama of the Scottish landscape they are travelling through and then a little later there is a lovely night time view as they approach Edinburgh. The pictures have a timeless feel, whilst this book was first published only a couple of years ago it already has a classic feel to it.

This book is the twelfth book in the Katy series by James Mayhew, on the strength of this I’ll be looking out for the others on my future trips to the library.

Steggie’s Stammer by Jack Hughes. Wayland.
SteggieSteggie has a stammer and sometimes it takes her more time to get her words out. Her friends are in a hurry to play a game and they rush off without listening to her.

Before long, the friends get into trouble and it’s up to Steggie to rescue them. But will they listen to her advice?

I was drawn to this book both by its very appealing cover and it’s intriguing title. This book clearly was going to deal with stammering, something that affects lots of young children (about 5% of children go through a stammering phase with 1 in 5 of these being at risk of persistant stammering). I wondered how well it would manage the topic – there’s always a risk that books with such a specific purpose can be a little cheesy or worthy. Seeing that the Education Office for the British Stammering Association had acted as a consultant made me think it would probably avoid these pitfalls, I started to read with great hope.

The story is a simple one, Steggie and her friends are playing and her friends won’t give her the time she needs to speak instead interrupting and going off to do their own thing. This naturally goes wrong, and Steggie comes through to save the day with her friends learning that they need to listen to her and give her time to talk. The message is strong but does avoid feeling preachy, I think the book would definitely be enjoyed by its target age group. The illustrations are attractive, they often give the impression of being at least part done with wax crayons which gives them great child appeal.

Upon finishing the book I discovered that this is one book from a set of 4, Steggie’s 3 dinosaur friends all get their own book – I assume serving a similar purpose. I had noticed that Rex wore glasses and Dachy had a hearing aid, though must admit I didn’t spot Emmy’s eczema. I would imagine that these books would make a good addition to any childcare setting’s picture book collection.

Both books featured in this post were borrowed from my local library.

Advertisements

One thought on “PoP: Katie in Scotland by James Mayhew & Steggie’s Stammer by Jack Hughes.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s